Philosophy & Religion   215 Bioethics    
Fall 2012 Dr. Candace Gauthier    

Course Requirements

1.  Attendance at all classes is expected.  Numerous absences will definitely affect your ability to satisfactorily meet the goals of this course.

2. The use of electronic devices, including cell phones and computers, in not permitted during class. Please leave the classroom if you need to use your phone or computer.

3.  Reading the articles and cases assigned for each class is essential.  The assigned readings form the basis for your understanding and participation in class discussions as well as for writing papers and preparing for exams.  You must bring the assigned text to class every day. 

 4. Participation in class discussions is strongly encouraged.  Active engagement with others in the consideration of ethical issues is central to the development of critical analysis skills and a well-supported personal position.

5.  You will write three papers during the semester.  The first is a paper applying material we have covered in class to a case in the delivery of health care.  The second paper includes interviews and your own view on assisted suicide.  Each of these papers is worth 15 points. The third paper is a report on an article you will choose to present at the end of the course with a small group.  The presentation paper will be worth 10 points..  The papers are due on Tuesday September 18, Tuesday October 23, and on the day of your group's presentationLate papers will be marked down one point for each day late.

Paper assignments and other handouts will be available through links on my website.  You are responsible for accessing these to use in preparing your papers.

6. You will present one of the articles in the text that we have not covered in class with a small group.  You will be given time in class to prepare for this presentation.

7. There will be three exams during the semester. The first exam is on Thursday September 27.  The second exam is on Thursday October 25.  The final exam is on Tuesday December 11 at 3 PM for the 3:30 PM class and Thursday December 13 at 3 PM for the 2 PM class.

8. Each exam is worth 20 points.  Make-up exams will not be available, except in extraordinary circumstances. The exams for this course include definitions, concepts, and arguments argument based on the assigned readings, handouts, and class discussions.  Final grades will include “plus” modifiers when appropriate.

9. The final grade will be based on the addition of the points earned on the exams and papers. A = 90+ points, B = 80+ points, and C = 70+ points.

 

  Office Hours: 
Office:  Bear Hall 272                        Tuesday       1:30 - 2:00 PM
Home Phone:  256-6419                        Wednesday   6:00 - 6:30 PM
E-mail: gauthierc@uncw.edu                         Thursday      1:30 - 2:00 PM
Website: http://people.uncw.edu/gauthierc/                        Other times by appointment  

                  

     The purpose of this course is to introduce students to the philosophical area of bioethics, the study of right and wrong behavior in the delivery of health care and medical research, through critical reading, discussion, and writing.  The student learning outcomes of the course are (1) to describe and explain the ethical theories and ethical principles that apply to health care delivery and medical research, (2) to explain and critically analyze the various positions and arguments concerning  controversial ethical issues in health care and medical research, (3) to develop a personal position on these ethical issues and provide supporting arguments for this position.

 

Text: Contemporary Issues in Bioethics, Beauchamp and Walters, SIXTH EDITION

 

Required Readings and Discussion Topics

Thurs. Aug. 23 Introduction and  Syllabus

 

Tues. Aug. 28 Ethical Theory
  pp. 1-21
 
Thurs. Aug. 30 Ethical Principles
  pp. 21-33
THE PATIENT-PHYSICIAN RELATIONSHIP  

 

Tues. Sept. 4 Professional Codes
  The Hippocratic Oath
  Fundamental Elements of the Patient-Physician Relationships
  Principles of Medical Ethics
   
Thurs. Sept. 6 Truth-telling
  Arguments and Discussion
  Small Group Discussion
   
Tues. Sept. 11 Informed Consent
  Canterbury v. Spence, pp. 139-141
  Jay Katz, pp. 141-145
   
Thurs. Sept. 13 Confidentiality
  Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, pp. 119-123
  Mark Siegler, pp. 116-118
   
Tues. Sept. 18 Video on the Application of Ethical Theories
  Review of Ethical Theories
  *CASE PAPER DUE
   
Thurs. Sept. 20 Justice
  Norman Daniels, pp. 46-52
   
Tues.  Sept. 25 Review of Ethical Principles and Their Application
  Small Group Discussion of Cases
  Questions and Review for Exam
   
Thurs. Sept. 27 FIRST EXAM
 END-OF-LIFE ISSUES  

 

 

Tues. Oct. 2 Refusal of Medical Treatment
  Bouvia v. Superior Court, pp. 156-159
   
   
Thurs. Oct. 4 Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health, pp. 159-163
  North Carolina Advance Directive for a Natural Death

North Carolina Health Care Power of Attorney

   
Thurs. Oct. 11 Active Euthanasia
  Dan Brock, pp. 216-225
   
   
Tues. Oct. 16 Euthanasia Arguments
  Small Group Discussion of Cases
   
Thurs. Oct. 23 Assisted Suicide
  Timothy Quill
  Oregon Death with Dignity Act, pp. 201-204
   
   
   
Tues. Oct. 25 Discussion of Assisted Suicide Interviews
  *ASSISTED SUICIDE PAPER DUE
  Questions and Review for Exam
   
   
Thurs. Oct. 25 SECOND EXAM
 MEDICAL RESEARCH  

 

 

Tues. Oct. 30 Research Codes
  The Nuremberg Code, P. 354
  The Declaration of Helsinki and Note of Clarification , pp. 355-358
 
Thurs. Nov.1 International Perspectives
  Baruch Brody, pp. 365-370
 
   
Tues. Nov. 6 The Tuskegee Study and the Government Response
  Gregory Pence, pp.  394-401
  The Belmont Report
   
Thurs. Nov. 8 Cloning Human Beings
  Dan Brock, pp. 593-602
  National Bioethics Advisory Commission, pp. 618-620
   
Tues. Nov. 13 Discussion of Cloning Human Beings
  Small Group Meetings to Plan Presentations
   
SMALL GROUP

PRESENTATIONS

 

 
   
   
   
Thurs. Nov.15 Small Group Presentations
  Readings to be assigned
   
   
Tues. Nov. 20 Small Group Presentations
  Readings to be assigned
   
Tues. Nov. 27 Small Group Presentations
  Readings to be assigned
   
Thurs. Nov. 29 Small Group Presentations
  Readings to be assigned
   
Tues. Dec. 4 Small Group Presentation
  Readings to be assigned
  Questions and Review for Exam
   
   
   
   
FINAL EXAM Tuesday December 11 at 3 PM for the 3:30 PM class

Thursday December 13 at 3 PM for the 2 PM class