Home
Up

Memo #3 - Book Review
 
Directions:

You are required to read the following book:

 

bullet

Wheeler, Richard S. 1998. The Buffalo Commons. New York, NY: Tor Books. ISBN 0812545168 

 

It is available at the bookstore and can be purchased at various online vendors.  It is a timely novel that touches on many of the issues we will discuss this semester.  In particular, this fictional story of what happens when people with good intentions clash over their ideas of what the earth is for and how life must be lived on it.  Thus, the novel highlights many of the value conflicts and the tensions between those who want to preserve the land and those that want to manage it for multiple uses.  After reading the novel, you are required to write a critique and review of the book.   Essentially, your critique should answer the following question: Does the book accurately portray environmental politics? You have a lot of freedom in terms of how you approach the critique and there is some room for creativity. However, be sure you consider the theories and concepts discussed in class when writing your critique.  You may also want to consider some of the following questions:

 

bullet

How does the book portray environmentalists?  How does it portray developers?  How does it portray ranchers? How does it portray environmental agency officials?  Are these accurate portrayals? 

bullet

What role does science play in the political process described in the book?  Is this an accurate portrayal of the role of science?

bullet

Can science provide objective, value free information?  What is natural?

bullet

How are conflicts between preservation and multiple use portrayed in the book?

bullet

Were you satisfied with the ending? 

bullet

If there really was a wealthy billionaire trying to do what is described in the book do you think it would meet with the same problems?

bullet

Ultimately, how realistic do you think the book is?  Where does it go too far?  Where does it not go far enough?

 

Your critique is limited to 6 double-spaced pages with 12 point font and 1 inch margins.

Back to Mark T. Imperial's Homepage

Page last modified 03/09/05

Report problems to imperialm@uncw.edu