Overview and History:
What is psychopathology?--It is the field concerned with the nature and development of abnormal thoughts, feelings and behaviors.
Difficulties with this definition:
1) ambiguity- the field is defined by its' questions rather than its' answers
2) objectivity-the subject nature is personal making objectivity all the more important. Everyone has experienced some abnormal symptoms personally, interpersonally or in news reports. Two problems with this:
A) medical student syndrome
B) experiential vs. scientific frame of reference (Paul Meehl "Why I don't go to case conferences")
Class exercise: What is abnormal? What is normal?
Within the field of psychopathology we ask:
1. What is abnormal behavior?
Characteristics include:
A. Statistical infrequency-Normal curve Behavior is considered abnormal to the extent that it deviates from the average (MR as an example) BUT some very infrequent behaviors are not pathological (e.g. athletic ability). The statistical approach does not tell us which particular behaviors we should abnormal.
B. Violation of social norms- abnormality is treated as relative to some social standard (e.g. anorexia or OCD rituals) BUT some behavior clearly violates social norms but is not considered abnormal (e.g. prostitution) and other behavior is considered clearly abnormal but does not violate social norms. (e.g. simple phobia). ALSO cultural diversity can affect how people view social norms- what is normal in one society is abnormal in another.
C. Personal Distress- behavior is considered abnormal to the extent that it creates distress (e.g. depression and anxiety) BUT some disorders do not necessarilly involve distress (e.g. psychopathy) and some forms of distress are not abnormal (e.g. hunger). Also discomfort levels rely on subjective ratings and it is therefore difficult to compare one individual with another.
D. Disability or Dysfunction- behavior is abnormal to the extent that it causes some impairment in some important area of life (e.g. substance abuse) BUT certain diagnostic categories are not known to cause disability (e.g. transvestism with distress) and many disabilities Are not considered within the purview of "abnormal behavior" 9e.g. blindness.
E. Unexpectedness. Behavior is considered abnormal to the extent to which it is an unexpected response to environmental stressors. 9e.g. anxiety disorder) BUT certain behaviors may be quite markedly deviant but not be unexpected (e.g. addictive behaviors)
The best definition is probably a combination of A-E, that is behavior is abnormal to the extent that it represents a marked deviation from established societal norms and causes distress to self or others.
Who is concerned with abnormal behavior?
1. Clinical psychologists-Ph.D. or Psy.D who have further training in the area of assessment and diagnosis and the practice of psychotherapy. Psy.D. has more of a focus on therapy than research.
2. Psychiatrists- Mds who complete a residency in diagnosis and psychotherapy who prescripe psychotropics (current war over prescription privileges)
3. Psychoanalysts
4. Social workers (M.S.W)
5. Counseling psychologists- similar to clinical but less emphasis on research
6. Psychopathologists- individuals who conduct research into the nature and development of various disorders (can be clinical, biochemical, developmental, etc.)
History of Psychopathology
Earliest theories concerning the causes of abnormal behavior invoked supernatural forces.
Prevailing theory- Deviancy reflects the displeasure of the gods or possession by demons.
Early demonology (prior to 400 B.C.):
Theory: Evil beings (e.g. the devil) cause deviant behavior. Many cultures subscribed to this view (e.g. early chinese, Greeks and Hebrew, Biblical accounts of possession (Mark 5:8-13)
Treatment: Exorcism (or similar rites) Exorcism is the casting out of evil spirits by chanting ritual or prayer. In ancient times it also included such practices as flogging and starvation so that the body would not be attractive to evil spirits.
Somatogenic Theories: Some that is wrong with the soma (physical body) is the cause of disturbance in thought and action. (Psychogenesis-disturbance has psychogenic origins.)
Hippocrates (early fifth century; father of modern medicine, individual who separated modern medicine from religion magic and superstition)
-The gods do not send mental and physical disease in order to punish. Serious diseases are caused by natural factors (even mental disease) and should be treated like other diseases (e.g. colds) with natural remedies.
-The brain is the organ of consciousness, intellectual life and emotion=deviant thinking and behavior are indications of brain pathology.
Three categories of mental disorder:
1-mania
2- melancholia
3- phrenitis (brain fever)
-Normal brain functioning(and mental health) dependent on a balance among four humors(bodily fluids). Imbalane produces illness:
1. Blood (changeable temperment)
2. Black bile (melancholia)
3. Yellow bile (irritability and anxiety)
4. Phlegm (sluggish and dull)
Though the theory is wrong, the premise set the stage for modern medicine and the naturalistic or disease oriented approach to treatment that is used in modern medicine today.
Demonology (the Dark Ages, 200 A.D.) Followed the decline of the Greek and Roman empire). Several operative factors including:
1. Gain in influence of the church
2. Papacy was declared independent of the state
3. Missionaries, through the establishment of monastaries replaced physicians as healers- particularly of those with mental disorders.
A. Related development was treating the mentally ill as possessed by the devil (13th century until now)
Operative factors/premises appeared to include:
1. Withcraft is caused by the devil
2. 1484 papal bull by Pope Innocent VIII encouraging identification of witches. This marked the beginning of the Inquistion.
1510 Malleus Maleficarum (Hammer of the witches a guide to witch hunts became the textbook on witches) was published. Subjected accused to torture, convicted to life imprisonment and unrepentent to execution. Specified that sudden loss of reason was a symptom of demon possession which shoud be "treated" by burning. Estimates of 500-800,000 men, women and children died because of this.
3) The best known American witchcraft trials were in Massachusetts in 1692- hundreds of people falsely accused and imprisoned- 20 killed
Witchcraft was not the only explanation for mental illness at this time. In larger cities laws were being passed to "confine" the mentally ill. The laws did not mention witchcraft. First lunacy trials were actually held in Britain the 1200's. During that time it was established that:
1. Trials could be conducted under the Crown's right to protect the mentally impaired.
2. A judgment of insanity allowed the court to become guardian of the lunatic's estate.
3. Issues in the trials included defendent's orientation, memory, daily life etc.
4. Causal explanations included physical illness or emotional shock.
The Masturbatory Insanity Hypothesis
Theory based causal explanation
The beginnings of contemporary thought:
The return to somatogenic theories in the early 1500's (coocurred with the reemergence of a scientific or professional class. Autopsies were again allowed)
Some major advances/figures in this time:
1) Willam Griesinger- German physician- any diagnosis of mental disorder must specify a physical cause.
Emil Kraeplin was his student. Kraeplin devised a classification system of mental illness in 1883.
Discovered certain symptoms-which he called syndromes tend to cooccur.
Each syndrome has its own distinct genesis, symptoms, course and outcome
Two types of syndromes:
Dementia praecox-schizophrenia- caused by a chemical imbalance
Manic-depressive psychosis- irregularity in metabolism
Kraeplins idea of classifying symptoms in this way is the basis for our current classification scheme DSM-IV
Using Kraeplin's scheme we may not be able to cure disease but we can predict their course.
2) The discovery of the nature and origin of syphilis
In 1825 general paresis was given disease status- the syndrome included steady deterioration of mental and physical capabilities as well as delusions of grandeur and paralysis
1857- It was discovered that some people who had general paresis had previously suffered from syphilis (a venereal disease) The search for a cause was on and included seawater (sailors) liquor and tobacco (men).
1860's-1870's Louis Pasteur established the germ theory of disease
Disease is caused by infection of the body by minute organisms
1897- Richard von Krafft-Ebing inocualted paretic patients with material from syphlitic sores. The paretic patients did not develop syphilis which proved they had been infected earlier.
1905-The specific organism causing syphilis was discovered
For the first time a biological cause had been discovered for a form of psychopathology!!!!!
Psychogenesis (late 1700's until now) started in Austria and France
The psychogenic view- mental disorders are caused by psychological dysfunctions.
Came about as a result of the wave of "Hysteria" in that time
Proponents included:
Franz Mesmer- hysterival disturbances are caused by disturbances in the magnetic fluid of the body.
Used hypnosis or mesmerisn to achieve cures
This led to the study of hypnosis-Jean Charcot- scientifically showed how suggestion can lead to the amelioration of symptoms.- led to an increased interest in nonphysiological explanations of physiological problems.
Josef Breuer- The case of Anna O. Led to the "cathartic method"
Breuer's work was an immediate precursor to Freuds.
History of modern clinical Psychology
1) Development of asylums.- Asylums began to appear in the fifteenth century as leprosariums began to be converted to refuges for the confinement of the mentally ill.
-Inmate were a mixture of beggars and MI (Paris in the 1500's had 100.000 people, 30,000 of whom were beggars)
-The only treatment was to get them to work
2) The priory of St. Mary of Bethlehem (founded 1243) was handed over to Henry VIII for the sole purpose of treatment of the mentally ill in 1547.
-origin of the word "bedlam"
-bigtime tourist attraction with good ticket sales
Viennese equivalent had special rooms where inmates could be "viewed"
3) First mental hospital in America was in Williamsburg in 1773. Its first keeper had formerly headed the public gaol.
This is really page 16
Example. An examination of the effect of therapy (three levels) in groups of patients divided on the basis of severity of illness
Type of therapy is the experimental variable
Severity is the grouping variable. This variable is not manipulated. It just is. Therefore we have the same problems interpreting its effect as we do with correlations.
If therapy is differentially effective for different groups the pattern of results will be different than if therapy is similarly effective for different groups. This differential effect is what tells us the most in experimental and mixed designs- if we see a differential deficit or advantage we can rule out other hypothesis (e.g. treatment differences are less likely to be caused by random error factors such as history or selection)
This type of effect is called an interaction
A direct effect is called a main effect
Diagnostic Assessment
First systematic classification scheme developed in Paris in 1889 but it
was not used
First U.S. system, 1886, from the Association of Medical Superintendents
of American Institutions for the Insane (forerunner of the American Psychiatric
Association-
1913- AMSA adopted Kraeplin’s scheme (not used by all organizations)
1939 World Health Organization added mental disorders to the International
List of Causes of Death
1948 WHO expanded the list. It became the International Statistical
Classification of Diseases, Injuries and Causes of Death - a comprehensive
listing of all diseases including MI.
Wide acceptance of the classification of MI did not occur until the publication
of DSM-1 in 1952
1969- WHO published the International Classification of Diseases, 1968-
DSM-11- still true consensus had not been reached e.g. symptoms listed were
not always similar, therefore diagnostic practices varied.
1980- DSM-111 was published
1987-DSM-111-R, these DSM categories were more empirically , as compared
to theoretically derived.
-they also made explicit reasons for changes in diagnostic categories.
Work on DSM-IV began immediately after DSM-III was published- DSM-IV was
designed to resolve differences between the DSMs and the ICDs (e.g. psychopathy
appeared in the ICD but not the DSM-
These differences were published in a book call the DSM-IV Options Book
(1991)
DSM-IV published 1994
DSM-IV
Starting with DSM-III
1) use of multiaxial classification- each individual
is rated seperately on five dimensions (axes)
This forces the clinician to consider
a broad range of information
Axis One- Clinical disorders and other conditions that may be the focus
of Clinical Attention- all forms of mental illness except Mental Retardation
and Personality Disorders
Axis Two- Personality Disorders and Mental Retardation
Axes One and Two constitute the classification of abnormal behavior
They are seperated to make sure the effects of long
term disorders are not overlooked
e.g. Heroin addict and antisocial
personality disorder
The remaining three axes are not necessary in making a diagnosis (it is
already made on One and Two
What do the other three Axes do?- make sure that factors other than the
persons symptoms are included in making the assessment
Axis Three- General medical conditions believed to be related to the mental
disorder in question (e.g. hypothyroidism) (e.g. major depressive disorder
and hypothyroidism)
Axis IV- psychosocial and environmental problems that may be contributing
to the disorder (e.g. occupational or economic problems)
Axis IV- current level of adaptive functioning- Ratings of current functioning
give information about the need for treatment and prognosis.
_____________________________________________________________________
Axis 1
Mental disorders in Axis One
Axis One criteria are by number of symptoms and severity of symptoms.
To receive an Axis One diagnosis symptoms must be of sufficient severity
to cause significant distress or impairment in social or occupational functioning.
Disorders usually first diagnosed in Infancy, childhood or adolescence-
These are the intellectual, physical and emotional problems seen in childhood
and adolescence
They include:
1) Anxiety disorders of childhood (e.g. seperation-anxiety
disorder)
2) conduct disorder/ oppositional defiant disorder
3) mental retardation (coded on Axis II)
4) pervasive developmental disorders (e.g. autistic
disorder, Retts, CDD)
5) Learning Disorders (speech, reading, writing and
arithmetic)
2) Substance-Related Disorders- when the use of substances has changed
behavior enough to result in significant impairment in social or occupational
functioning
-usually defined as the person is unable to control
usage or diplays tolerance and withdrawal.
-Substance use can cause or contribut toother Axis One
disorders (e.g. Substance Induced persisting Amnestic
Disorder)
3) Schizophrenia- characterised by disturbances in cognition, perception
and emotion
-Also known as psychotic-contact with reality is lost
-typical symptoms are delusions (false beliefs) and
hallucinations (nonreality based perceptual experiences
-emotions are typically blunted, flattened or inappropriate
-causes serious impairment in social or ocuupational
functioning (though not ness. distress
4) Mood Disorders- primary diisturbance is in mood (either extremely high
or low)
1) Major depressive disorder- typical constellation
of sadness, discouragement, loss of energy and suicidality
2) Manic Disorder- mood is euphoric or irritable,
hyperactive and grandiose
3) Bipolar Disorder- diagnosed if the individuals experiences
episodes of mania or of mania or hypomania and depression
5) Anxiety Disorders- central disturbance is irrational or overblown fear.
1) phobia- fear and avoidance of a stimulus or situation
even though the individual is aware that fears are unreasonable
2) panic disorder- sudden, uncontrollable unexpected
attacks of intense apprehension with characteristic physical (cardiovascular)
symptoms
3) Agoraphobia- fear of being unable to escape from
a situation or of being unable to obtain help in the event of the experience
of a panic attack.
4) Generalized Anxiety Disorder Persistent unreasonable
feelings of apprehension for most of the time for at least six months
5) Obsessive-Compulaive disorder- Obsessions-recurrent
uncontrollable thoughts that the person experiences as ego-dystonic
Compulsions are irrisible behavioral impulses- Attempts to resist compulsions
produce untenable anxiety.
6) PTSD and ACST- characterised byexposure to a traumatic
stressor (e.g. one’s own death or the possibility of death.
Typical symptoms are; reexperiencing, avoidance and
heightened arousal.
6) Somatoform disorders- physical symptoms with no known physical basis
that seem to serve a psychological purpose- Does NOT mean the person is faking
Somatization Disorder- many physical complaints (Briquet’s
syndrome)
Conversion Disorder- odd, usually neurologic symptoms
pain disorder- severe and protracted pain
hypochondriasis- misinterpretation of minor physical
sensations as major physical illness.
Body Dysmorphic Disorder- Preoccupation with a imagined
defect in appearance
7) Dissociative Disorders- sudden alteration in consiousness that affects
memory and identity
-Dissociative amnesia- forgetting
of the past- either globally or a specific
time period
- Dissociative fugue- the individual
suddenly travels to a new locale and
assumes a new identity- is usally amnestic to the old identity
-Dissociative Identity Disorder (nee
MPD)- posseion of two or more personalities,
each complex and dominant one at a time.
8) Sexual and Gender Identity Disorders
-Paraphilias- sources of sexual gratification
are unconventional (e.g. foot fetish)
-Sexual dysfunctions- characterised
by the inability to complete the usual
sexual response cycle
-Gender Identity Disorders- experience
of extreme discomfort with own sex
and identification with the opposite sex
9) Sleep Disorders-
-Dyssomnias- sleep is disturbed in amount, quality or
timing
- parasomnias- an unusual event occurs during sleep
(e.g. night terror)
10) Eating Disorders
-Anorexia Nervosa- characterised by refusal to maintain
normal body weight , fear of gaining weight and
perceptual distortion
Two types- binge-purging, restricted
-Bulimia Nervosa-frequent episodes of binge eating (at
least twice per week for at least three months) coupled
with compensatory activities (e.g. compensatory vomiting)
11) Factitious Disorder- applied when people intentionally produce or complain
of physical or psychological symptoms- usually for the purpose of assuming
the sick role.
12) Adjustment Disorder- development of psychological symptoms following
the occurrence of a major life stressor.
13) Impulse Control Disorders- Characterised by inappropriate and out of
control behavior.
Intermittent Explosive Disorder-episodes
of violent behavior that result in
the destruction of property or injury to another person.
Kleptomania- repeated theft not for
use of object or money
Pyromania- purposeful firesetting
for pleasure
pathological gambling-preoccupation
with gambling as a way to escape life’s
problems
trichotillomania-irresistible impule
to pluck out hair.
14) Delirium, Dementia, Amnestic and other Cognitive Disorders (often associated
with aging)
-Delirium clouding of consciouness, wandering attention
and incoherent stream of thought (may be caused by medical
conditions or substance abuse)
-Dementia- deterioration of mental capacities, especially
memory
-Amnestic syndrome- impairment in memory where ther
is no dementia or delirium (often linked to alcohol abuse)
15) Other disorders that may be the focus of clinical attention-seems to
exist so that anyone entering the mental health system can be categorized
Examples include:
Academic problems
Antisocial behavior
Malingering
If a medical illness os caused or exacerbated by the psychological condition
the diagnosis is psychological factors affecting a physical condition.
Axis II
Personality Disorders
rigid, inflexible, maladaptive patterns of behavior
and experience
1) schizoid-person is aloof, has
few friends and is indifferent to criticism
2) antisocial personality disorder-
manifested before age fifteen and
characterised by a persistent pattern of antisocial or aggressive acts.
MR
Onset before age 18
WAIS-R less than 70
Issues in Classification:
1) Classification produces loss of information
2) Classification is stigmatizing
Value of classification
1) Classification enables us to determine cause and make treatment specific
to disorder
2) Classification allows us to further knowledge-we can study people who
fit the definition
Is the DSM reliable and valid
Reliability
1) For each disorder there are essential features, associated features,
lab findings, results from physical exams, relevant research findings re age
of onset, course, prevalence etc
This allows us to make cross-cultural comparisons.
E.g. the core symptoms of depression
and schizophrenia are consistent cross-culturally BUT
GUILT varies (frequest in Western cultures but infrequent
in Japan and Iran.
Depression in Latino cultures more
likely to involve somatic complaints
2) Specific diagnostic criteria are spelled out for each category=more
explicit than other DSMs
Thus the reliabilities for the major categories are pretty good (although
they vary, e.g. anxiety disorders)
BUT
1) some of the rules are a little arbitrary (e.g. number of symptoms required)
2) clinicians din’t always strictly adhere to the DSM in practice
AND
3) subjective judgments are still involved (e.g. GAF)
ALSO-
4) there is still some controversy over inclusion rules (e.g. should LD
be considered a psychiatric disorder)
The bottom line is- We have a long way to go
Theories of Psychopathology
All theories of Psychopathology are based on paradigms.
-Paradigms are sets of assumptions that go together to
define how to conceptualize, study, gather and interpret
data.
The Biological Paradigm
- an extension of the somatogenic hypothesis
-called the medical model or disease model
Our whole description of mental illnesses uses medical model terms
e.g., pathological, diagnosis & symptom
-we also talk in terms of treatment, disease and cures
MEDICAL disorders can be very different in cause but they share one characteristic
in common;
-some biological process is disrupted or nor functioning
normally
There is considerable evidence that biologiccal factors predispose the individual
to psychopathology
BUT- we should also be mindful of the fact that this is just a paradigm
Other paradigms say we lose maore by taking this informatuion into accountn
than we gain. ( e.g. existential accounts)
Given this what can we say about the biological paradigm:
Those working within the biological paradigm find causes to psychopathology
within the body.
Behavior Genetics- the study of individual differences in behavior that
are attributable in part to differences in genetic makeup.
-examines the role of genes
-thousands of genes make up chromosomes
-chromosomes are
the carriers of genetic information
-they are passed
from parent to child
-there are 23 pairs
Genotype= the individuals total genetic makeup
Phenotype= observable characteristics
The phenotype changes over time and is a product of the interaction between
the phenotype and experience.
-intelligence is an example of phenotype.
-clinical syndromes of mental illnesses also represent
a phenotype
-therefore it is not proper to speak
of DIRECT inheritance of MI
- what is inherited is a genetic diathesis
or predisposition
-the diathesis
is inherited not the disease
-the environment determines whether
the diathesis will be activated or become
manifest.
-therefore we speak of diathesis-stress
theories of mental illness.
Behavior genetics relies on three methods to study MI
1) The family method- used to compare members of a family
-useful in families because the average genes shared
by two blood relatives is known
-e.g. children receive 50% of genes
from each parent
-people who share
50% of genes are called first-degree relatives
=parents siblings and children
-relatives who
are not as closely related share fewer genes
-nieces and nephews
share 25% of their genetic inheritance with
uncles.
-The starting point in family investigations is the individual
who has the diagnosis
=the INDEX CASE or proband
-relatives are then studied to determine the frqency
the diagnosis applies to them
If a genetic predisposition towards a disease is present relatives should
have the disorder at a higher rate than found in the general population.
Closer relatives should have higher rates than less close
relatives
The twin method-
Involves comparison of MZ and DZ twins
-within and across twin comparisons
-MZ twins develop
from a single fertilized egg.
-genetically ALMOST the same
-DZ twins from
separate eggs= 50% alike genetically
Twin studies begin with the twin with the disorder and then search for the
presance of the disorder in the other twin.
-Concordant twins are similar diagnostically
-IF a predispostion toward a disorder is INHERITED
than MZ>DZ
BUT twin studies are usually confounded by similar environments
e.g. twins are treated more similarly than siblings or
even same sex siblings
ALSO twins that have the disorder are more likely to have parents that have
the disorder (if genetic trasmission of a disorder is true)
What do scientists do?
They use the equal environment assumption=
-for whatever diagnosis being studied environmental forces
that are causative are about equivalent for MZ and DZ twins.
-therefore difference in concordance
rates are due to genetics
Twin research allows us to draw better inferences about the contribution
of genetic factors than the family method.
A better way?
Study adopted children who have never been reared by their biological parents.
BEST twins who are seperated from birth and never raised by their biological
parents.
- high concordance under these circumstances
makes it more likely that the disorder is inherited.
Biochemistry in the nervous system
1) Neuron
-cell body
-dendrites
-axons
-terminal buttons
2) Appropriate stimulation causes a nerve impulse to travel through the
dendrite, through the cell body and down the axon.
-the nerve impulses cause the synaptic vescicles in the
terminal buttons to release neurotransmitters
-nerve impulses travel across the synaptic cleft to the
receptor site of the postsynaptic neuron
- any neurotrasmitter left in the synapse is pumped back
into the presynaptic neuron through a process called reuptake.
3) Neurotransmitters implicated in psychopathology
Too much or too little of any neurotranmitter causes psychopathology
The assumption behind psychopharmacology
Psychoactive drugs either increase the amount of a neurotransmitter at a
receptor site OR block reuptake in the synatic cleft
It is also possible that too much neurotransmitter is related to too many
postsynaptic recetors
A) Norepinephrine- one of the catecholamines
-involved in the production of arousal
states
-abnormally low levels are associated
with depression
-high levels associated with mania
B) Serotonin
-mediates the effects of reward and
punishment
- low levels associated with depression
-Prozac increases
neural transmission in serotonin neurons by
inhibiting the reuptake of serotonin
D. Dopamine
-connected with reward centers and,
possibly motor centers
-low levels associated with schitzophrenis
-high levels associated with Parkinson’s
Disease
-thorazine reduces
the activity of dopamine neurons by blocking
their receptors
E. GABA- Gamma-aminobutyric acid
-INHIBITS some nerve impulses
-deficiency allows arousal to occur
-involved in anxiety disorders
-tranquilizers
such as Valium stimulate GABA receptors
Biological approaches to treatment
Prevention or treatment of mental disorder is possible
by altering bodily functioning.
1) one way is to provide the chemical
2) The other way is to prevent degradation of the chemical
The only way we can do One & Two is if we know the CAUSE of a disorder
-we don’t always know cause
-we don’t know if the biology produced the syndrome or
is a consequence of the syndrome
Psychological syndromes have been
shown to CAUSE somatic changes.
-even if we know biology NONbiological therapies can
be just as effective
-so why give bio with the side effects
Problems with the biological approach:
One problem is reductionism= reducing complex emotional process to biological
components
-extreme form= Psychology is nothing more than biology
BUT is Psychology we know that the whole is larger than the sum of its parts
Irrational thought processes cannot whole be defined on the basis of biology
e.g. where is the neuron for catastrophizing?
The PA Paradigm
Id- contains the libido
operates by the pleasure principle
governed by primary process thinking- short term wish fulfillment through
fantasy
unconscious processes
most of the important determinants of the psyche are
in the unconscious
Ego-develops after the id
secondary process thinking- governed by the reality principle
The ego has to mediate between the demands of reality and the demand odf
the id
BUT the ego gets all its energy from the id
like a horseback rider who relies upon the horse for momentum but
must also gevern the horse.
Superego- our conscience
develops from the ego like ego from id
Occurs as children introject parental values
PSYCHODYNAMIC= the complex interplay of the three parts of the psyche
Personality develops through four psychosexual stages
a different part of the body is most senstive to sexual
excitement at each stage
birth-18mths= oral stage
18 mths -3 yrs= anal stage
3-5 or six = phallic
Six- twelve is latency
Genital 12-up
During the plallic stage The OEDIPAL crisis is reached for male
The Electra for female
Through the introjection of same sex parent values the superego develiops
People becomes fixated at any one stage due to over or undergratification
of their wishes
We continue to act on our unconscious wished until the conflicts associated
with the stage are resolved
Neurotic Anxiety occurs as a result of FEAR that our unconscious impulses
were allowed expression
e.g. dirt phobics are acting out of fear developed during
toliet training as a result of overly strict or diapproving parents
The essence of neurosis is repression
Being unaware of conflicts (repression) is the core of neurotic anxiety
Individuals who are aware of conflicts don’t feel the tension and the need
to act on conflicts
Defense mechanisms
We reduce the discomfort caused by anxiety by the use of defense mechanisms.
These include:
Repression (most common)- Unacceptable impulses are pushed into the unconscious
Projection (paranoia)
Displacement
Reaction formation (convertint an unacceptable feeling into its opposite
Rationalization
Sulimation
Defense mechanisms are grouped and are stage specific (Valliant)
Psychotic
Immature
Neurotic
Mature
Psychopathology results:
1) the defense mechanisms are inadequate at modulating the level of unconcious
conflict
BUT remember there are specific forms of unconcious conflict associated
with each stage
Therefore pathology is stage specific (e.g. phobias are the result of unresolved
and displaced Oedipal fears)
Psychopathology is also the result of inappropriate use of defense mechanisms
(e.g. overreliance on one particular defense mechanism)
Neofreudian Perspectives
Jung- Analytical Psychology
Jung introduced the terms personal and collective unconscious
The collective unconscious contains universally shared neural patterns=
archetypes
They are both positive (e.g. persona) and negative (shadow)
masculine (animus) and feminine (anima)
Jung also introduced the personality typology “intraversion/ extraversion
and described midlife as a transition from E to I.
People have to be understood in terms of their dreams and aspirations as
well as their past.
Adler- Individual Psychology
Adler looked at the effect of the psychosocial environment on the individual
He specifically focued on how feelings of INFERIORITY and the development
of an INFERIORITY COMPLEX influences behavior
Adlers work heavilly influenced our current educational practices
Ego Psychologists:
Erikson and psychosocial stages of development
Erikson is an ego psychologist= emphasizes the independence of the ego from
the id and the adaptive functions of the ego
Erikson started the field of life-span development and extended Freuds notion
of developmental stages throughout the life span
Erikson- Eight stages of psychsocial development
Trust vs. Mistrust
0-1
Autonomony vs. Shame 1-3
Iniative vs. Guilt
3-6
Industry vs. Inferiority 7-11
Identity vs role confusion 12-20
Intimacy vs isolation 20-30
Generativity vs. Stagnation 30-65
Ego Integrity vs. Dispair 65+
Erikson is most famous for the term “identity crisis”
The identity crisis is the transition from childhood to adulthood- it is
the time we create a sense of self
What are we concerned with?
What kinds of things are going to
be important to us?
What kind of person do we want to
be?
The identity crisis comes at the same time people are
coming to terms with their
sexualty so it can be a real difficult time
Other famous developmental (lifespan theorists) include Piaget
Piaget talked about cognitive development
His stages were:
1. sensorimotor- principle of object permanence
2. Preoperational- Developing capacity for symbols
Thinking is egocentric, animistic
3. Concrete operations
NeoFreudians or Object Relations Theorists
Object relations theories deals with early childhood relationships and the
way we develop internal representations of the self and others.
Theorists include Kernberg, Mahler & Kohut
Object relations theory had been primarilly applied to the study and treatment
of personality disorders
Anxiety Disorders
Depression and anxiety are the “common colds” of mental illness.
Anxiety is a psychpathological state AND part of “normal” existence.
-without some anxiety we could do nothing
Anxiety used to be classified under “neuroses”= all neuroses were defined
as reflecting a problem with repressed anxiety
the problem with the concept of “neurosis” is that it
became all inclusive and meant nothing- everyone was characterised
by neurosis
-in DSM-IV neuroses are actually several categories (anxity
disorders are just one.
All anxiety disorders are characterised by subjectively experienced feelings
of anxiety that cause marked distress or interfere with social or occupational
functioning.
There is often “comorbidity” among anxiety disorders Why?
1. The symptoms of various anxirty
disorders are not entirely disorder specific
2. Current theories of etiology
apply to more than one disorder. So the same
cause could give rise to different disorders.
There are six principal categories of anxiety disorders
1) Phobias
2) Panic Disorder
3) Generalized Anxiety Disorder
4) Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder
5) Post-traumatic Stress Disorder
6) Acute Stress Disorder
1) Phobias
A phobia is disrupting, fear-mediated, avoidance that
is:
A) out of proportion to the danger
posed by a particular object or situation
B) Recognised by the sufferer as groundless
The suffix is from the God “Phobos” who frightened his enemies
Most common are
1) Specific phobias
2) Claustrophobia
3) Acrophobia
More exotic include:
1) nictophobia
2) thaphephobia (fear of being buried alive)
3) triskaedephobia
Most phobias do NOT come to the attention of shrinks (do not cause distress
or significant impairment in functioning)
1) Specific phobias= unwarranted fears caused by the presance or anticipation
of a specific object or situation
Lifetime prevalence= 7% male
16% female
DSM-IV subdivides specific phobias according to source:
1) blood and injections (most common among medical students
2) situations (e.g. planes and elevators)
3) animals
4) the natural environment
Exactly what is feared can vary cross-culturally and also with current trends
(e.g. Jaws)
2) Social Phobias= persistent irrational fear linked to the presance of other
people (can be extremely debilitating)
-typically it is characterised by avoidance behavior and
is related to fears of evaluation or embarrassment in social situations
-social phobias can be generalized or specific (generalized
tied to ETOH abuse and early onset)
-fairly common Lifetime prevalence = 11% men
15% women
-HIGH comorbidity with other anxiety disorders (e.g. GAD)
-onset usually during late adolescence
-specific fears vary by culture (e.g. in U.S. is fear
of evaluation
Etiology
P/A
Freud- phobias are a defense against the anxiety produced by repressed id
impulses
anxiety produced by the id impulse is displaced to an
object with which it has a symbolic connection.
-By avoiding the phobic object the individual is able
to avoid dealing with repressed conflicts
SO a phobia is the ego’s way of warding off a confrontation with the real
problem- a repressed childhood conflict
e.g. case of Little Hans was Hans’ intense fear of his father displaced onto
horses.
Evidence restricted to case reports
Behavioral Theories
Primary assumption is that phobias are learned
Classic experiemnt is Watson & Raynors study of “Little Albert”
-based on Mowrer’s two-factor theory of avoidance conditioning
The problem with this theory is that the research evidence suggests that
fear can be acquired without conditioning
e.g. many people report airplane phobias without a prior
untoward incident
-50% of people with dog phobias have
no untowrd prior incident.
I
Also attempts to replicate Watson & Raynor have been unsuccessful
What other theories
1) Seligman preparedness theory
2) Bandura= modeling= vicarious learning= watching others “suffer” can induce
a fear reaction in us.
Sue Mineka combined 1 & 2 in her work with rhesus monkeys =showed that
fear could be acquired through modeling only to certain stimuli
Behavioral theories cannot tell us why some individuals have phobias who
have not been exposed to modeled fear OR why some people who HAVE been exposed
do not display phobias
Cognitive Theories
Anxiety is linked to selective attention to negative stimuli
e.g. social phobia is tied to selective attention to evaluative
cues and increased self-consciousness
-the Stroop paradigms would speak to this
Biological Theories
1) Research indicates that there are stable differences in autonomic system
functioning
(=stable-labile ANS)
2) Genetic studies indicate higher genetic contribution to some phobias than
others
e.g. blood & injection show 64% concordance with first
degree relative
-prevalence in pop is 3-4%
-prevalence is also higher in 1st degree relatives for
social and specific phobia
Therapies- Most people do NOT sek treatment
P/A all p/a therapies attempt to uncover repressed sonflicts assumed to underlie
fears
the phobia is a symptom-it is not dealt
with directly
-uses free association to find unconscious conflict
-ego psychologists talk about a “corrective emotional
experience in therapy
Panic Disorder- Sudden and often unexpected feelings of intense apprehension
and impending doom coupled with typical physiological sensations (cardiovascular,
respiratory, feelingas of choking and smotherieng, nuasea, sweating and trembling,
dizziness)
Typical accompanying feelings
1) fears of loss of control
2) Depersonaliztion
3) Derealization
May occur frequently (DSM criteria is at least 2 attacks followed by at least
one month of worry about another attack
Typcally only last for minutes (feels like hours)
When strongly associated with certain situations called “cued panic attacks”
if ONLY cued are usually a phobia
Lifetime prevalence= 2% males 5% females
Typically begins in adolescence and is associated with the presance of a
stressful lifestyle
occurs cross-culturally e.g. kayak angst in eskimos
Panic Disorder is diagnosed with and without agoraphobia
80% of patients diagnosed with other anxiety disorders have panic attacks
also highly comorbid with ETOH and MDD
Etiology
1) genetics= gretaer concordance in MZ than DZ
2) biology= A. overactivity in the noradrenergic system
B Hi lactate (e.g. muscular exertion))
can produce panic
C. Hi CO2 can produce panic (=hyperventilation?)
The research does
not support C
3) Psychological= fear of fear -PD is a fear of having a panic attack
A) people have physiological sx and misinterpret them
in a catastrophic way leading to a panic attack. (E.g patients misled about
room levels of CO2
-there is some evidence to support
this
B) control- Panic Disorder results from a fear of losing
control
-perceived control appears to be most
important
In one study 80%
Therapy
1) Rx effective but A) relapse occurs following discontinuation of
drug
B) some drugs (e.g. benzos addicting
and have cognitive and motor effects.
2) Exposure (Barlow) can be quite effective- esp in vivo for agoraphobia
3) CBT involving reinterpretation of cognitive sensations= 3 components
1=relaxation, 2= Beckian 3= exposure to internal physiological
cues
patient experiences panic under safe
conditions and learns to apply cognitive
and relaxation tactics
Patient learns that
internal cues are harmless and can be
controlled
CBT more effective in the long term than RX
Generalized Anxiety Disorder- characterized by persistent anxiety and chronic,
uncontrollable worry occurring more days than not for at least six months
-aka “free floating anxiety
-somatic complaints are frequent=hyperactive ANS activity
-also frquent is anger or irritibility
- typically do NOT seek treatment
-lifetime prevalence is about 5%
-typically begins in midteens and is 2ce as common in
females than males
Etiology
P/A= unconcious conflicts between ego and id (usually sexual or aggressive)
-the anxiety is unconscious and reflects unacceptable
id impulses= the person is anxious and does not know why
-in some ways the phobic is better
off because the anxiety is displaced onto
a specific object anbd can be avoided
-the person with
GAD has not developed this defense
C/B
Strict behavioral
Anxiety response is conditioned to a range of stimuli (not just one as with
phobia)
More cognitive= Anxiety represents a perception of lack of control over the
environment
-when we experience uncontrollability we get anxious
-research (e.g. CO2 studies) supports this view and emphasize
PERCEPTION of control
-research also supports the view that
predictibility increases the perception
of control
Other cognitive factors affecting GAD
-misperception of benign events as
harmful
-interpretation of ambiguous events
as threatening
Biological- Mixed genetic evidence
There IS some evidence that indicates GAD results from
defects in GABA system
-benzos reduce anxiety by blocking
release of GABA
Therapies
1) Systematic desensitization
2) Assertiveness training to address helplessness
3) Training in reappraisal
4) Anxiolytics are the most widely prescribed treatment-
-problem here is SE and tolerance and withdrawal
-bigger problem is relapse following drug withdrawal (attributionally
mediated)
OCD
Wegner black bear experiment
Characterized by the presence of obsessions or compulsions or both that is
severe enough to be time consuming (more than an hour
a day) or cause marked distress or significant impairment
-affects 2-3% of the population
obsessions- recurrent, intrusive thoughts that the person
recognizes as irrational and uncontrollable and cause
distress
-EVERYONE has some obsessive thoughts.
These interfere with normal functioning
-most frequent involve contamination
fears, fears of expressing some aggressive
or sexual impulse or fears of bodily dysfunction
compulsions- repetitive behavior or mental act, the goal
of which is to reduce distress (distress is usually associated
with an obsession)
-Person spends significant amounts
of time engaged in the obsessive behavior-
e.g 100s of times per day
Common compulsions involve cleanliness
and checking behavior
-true compulsions are experienced as
foreign behavior
-NOT something like
eating-this is pleasurable
-has devastating effects on individuals
and people in their environment
Etiology
P/A
Instinctual sexual or aggressive impulses that are not under control because
of poor toileting
Adler- compulsive acts represent attempts at mastery
Behavioral and CognitiveTheories
To account for compulsions
1. compulsions are learned behaviors maintained by their consequences (fear
reduction)
-research partially supports this for compulsions but
not obsessions
2. Compulsions may reflect a memory deficit for ACTIONS PERFORMED (not a
global deficit)
-compulsive checkers DO have poorer recall of prior actions
To account for obsessions
-deficits in ability to suppress unwanted thoughts- Wegner
-also the more we try and inhibit a
thought the more potent it is
Biological factors-
Genetics- Higher concordance among first depree relatives (=30%)
PET scans show abnormalities in frontal lobe functioning-excess focus on
self
And basal ganglia-motor problems (Tourettes)
Therapy
Extremely difficult to treat
1. Most prevalent is exposure and response prevention
2. Second most common is SSRI
3. Psychosurgery is used in refractory cases
Interestingly enough both 1 & 2 produce changes in the caudate nucleus
PTSD 1-3% of the pop = 2 million people(including children)
20% of Vietnema vets, 47% of rape victims
Extreme response to a severe stressor (the stressor must be outside the range
of normal human experience
Characterized by:
a. Increased anxiety
b. Avoidance
c. Numbing of emotional responses
Three types of symptoms
1. Reexperiencing the traumatic event- frequent recall and nightmares
2. Avoidance of stimuli associated with the event- may cause emotional
numbing (amnesia for the event and decreased responsiveness to others)
3. Symptoms of increased arousal- hypervigilance, exaggerated startle
response
Associated symptoms = guilt, depression, substance abuse, psychophysiological
disorders, depersonaliztion and derealization
Etiology
P/A-PTSD symptoms are a result of repressed memories
Biological- trauma activates the noradrenergic systemcausing levels of NE
to be higher in PTSD folks
Learning Theory= classical conditioning of the fear response
-symptoms follow Mowrers two factor theory
No theory of PTSD explains why some folks develop PTSD after a trauma and
other don’t- (although social support helps)
Acute stress disorder is diagnosed when symptoms interfere with social or
occupational functioning for one month or more
Tx=Imaginal exposure to confront fears and extinguish fear response
-group therapy for social support
Mood Disorders- Any disorders; cognitive, affective, motivational and vegetative
(including motor) sx
General characteristics-
Depression- emotional state characterized by sadness and apprehension, feelings
of worthlessness and guilt, social isolation, loss of interest or pleasure,
difficulties in concentration and memory and difficulties with sleep, appetite
and energy
--sx are cognitive, affective, motivational and vegetative
-in children manifests itself with somatic complaints
- in the elderly difficulties with concentration and memory
-the average untreated MDD episode lasts from 6-9 months.
Mania- mood state characterized by intense elation or irritibility accompanied
by hyperactivity, grandiosity, flight of ideas and difficulty concentrating
and difficulties with sleep
-sx are cognitive, affective, motivational and vegetative
-episodes last from days to months and symptoms appear
suddenly (within one or two days)
Two major mood disorders in DSM-IV: unipolar depression and bipolar disorder
Unipolar depression requires the presance of at least five symptoms for at
least two weeks
- either depressed mood or loss of interest and pleasure
MUST be one of the symptoms.
-very widespread (lifetime prevalence= 17%)
-2wce to 10 times as common in women
- more frequent in low SES
-most frequent among youg adults
-tends to be recurrent, 80% experience another episode
within one year
-15% becomes chronic depression (duration=>2
years)
- prevalence has been increasing (=higher societal stress
levels)
- if psychotic features are present, they are usually
mood congruent
Bipolar I Disorder- The essential feature is a clinical course characterized
by the occurrence of one or more manic, hypomanic or mixed episodes
-3 or more symptoms for at least one week
`
-mania, hypomania or a mixed episode MUST have occurred
- r/o GMC’s and substance abuse
- sx are cognitive, affective, vegetative and motivational
- a past MDD episode MAY have occurred
- much rarer than MDD= lifetime prevalence .4-1.6%
- 10-15% of MDD develop Bipolar I
- is recurrent= over 50% experience 4 or more episodes
and 90% experience more than one
-80% return to normal functioning between episodes
- 10- 15% commit suicide
Bipolar II (Recurrent Major Depressive Episodes with Hypomanic Episodes)
- essential feature is a clinical course characterized
by the occurrence of one or
more major depressive episodes accompanied by at least
one hypomanic episode
- the individual CANNOT have had a
manic or mixed episode
- individuals are often not aware of
the hypomanic episodes
- prevalence around .5%
-completed suicide 10-15%
- tends to be recurrent and 10-15%
have 4 or more episodes
Mood Disorders can also be chronic- two types:
-Cyclothymia- For at least a 2 year period the person
has fluctuating symptoms of hypomania and depression but
symptoms are never severe enough to meet the criteria
for Bipolar 1 or Bipolar II
-the person is never symptom free for
more than 2 months
-Dysthymia= chronic depression for at least 2 years
Etiology
P/A-
Classical P/A= depression results from over or under gratification
or oral needs
-this causes people to be excessively
dependent on others for maintenance
of self-esteem
adult depression is a result of childhood loss of a loved
one- either through death or withdrawal of affection
-the child introjects
the loved one to undo the loss
-BUT
the child is angry at the loved one for the
abandonment and feels guilty
for real or imagined sins
against the lost person
-this
pruduces the feelings of guilt and self-blame
characteristic of depression
-
in P/A theory depression is literally griefwork gone astray
-research suggests
the depressed people ARE high in needs for
dependency
- also depression
IS more likely following a loss
-BUT depressed people
express hostility towards others NOT
inwardly
Biological Theories
Genetics
For bipolar disorder- concordance rates MZ twins = 72%,
DZ = 14%
-unipolar
MZ 46%, DZ = 20%
-there is a higher rate of mood disorder (unipolar and
bipolar) in first degree relatives of individuals with
bipolar rather than unipolar depressive disorder
linkage analysis= involves studying the occurrence of mood disorders over
seveal generations in conjuction with another characteristic whose genetic
marker is clearly understood (e.g. red-green color blindness)
-when the chromosomes for the mood disorder are closely
linked with the other characteristic, you can more easily
see the heritibility component of the mood disorder
-1987 study of the Amish indicated
that bipolar disorder results from a dominant
gene on the eleventh chromosome (not replicated)
Neurochemistry
Two neurotransmitters implicated
1. Excess NE leads to bipolar disorder
2. Low levels of serotonin lead to unipolar depressive
disorder
These theories derived mostly from drug research
-trycyclic antidepressant prevent the reuptake of serotonin
and NE
-this leaves more of the neurotransmitter
available making it more likely that
the neuron will fire
-MAO- Inhibitors keep monamine oxidase from deactivating
NE and serotonin
-this also increases levels of NE and
serotonin
-SSRIs are specific to serotonin and indicate a specific
link between serotonin levels and unipolar depression
Studies with of neurotransmitters
-urinary levels of NE are increased during mania and decreased
during depression
-increasing NE levels can precipitate
a manic episode
-A problem with this is that increased
activity levels can also account for these data
Studies with NE metabolites
urinary levels of NE metabolites are also higher in mania and lower in depression
-this could also reflect differences in activity level
Studies with serotonin metabolites
Serotonin metabolites are lower in the CSF of depressed patients
Ingesting tryptophan, a serotonin precursor, also helps with depression
-diets low in tryptophan can trigger depression recurrence
a big problem with studying metabolites is we cannot assess levels of the
neurotrasmitters in the brain (these neurotrasmitters also exist outside
the brain)
A second way of studying the effects or NE and serotonin is to look at the
effects of drugs on brain levels of the neurotransmitters
-a problem with this approach is that drus have multiple
effect- they don’t just effect one neurotransmitter
Drugs do effect NE and serotinin levels BUT
-research has shown that neurotrasmitters return to their
previous levels after several days of use
SO
a simple increase or decrease in neurotransmitter levels
cannot be accounting for the action of the drug
New research suggests that the mechanism of action is
actually on the postsynaptic receptors
(e.g SSRIs seem to increase the sensitivity of the receptors to serotonin)
lithium appears to work by affecting the proteins that carry information
across the synapse (thus it amplifies the neural signal)
The neuroendocrine system
1)Research implicates the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical axis
How do we know this
1) depressed patients have relatively high levels of cortisone
(an adrenocorticol hormone) -perhaps caused by an oversecretion
of a hormone from the hypothalamus
-high levels of cortisol led to the
development of the DST
-Dexamethasome suppresses
cortisol secretion
-Some
depressed patients fail to suppress cortisol when given DST (perhaps reflecting
overactivity in the HPA axis)
-failure to suppress ends when depression ends
2) Both depressed and bipolar patients often show thyroid problems
-hypo= depression
-hyper can induce mania
Cognitive Theories
1. Negative schemata (consist of the tendency to view the world in
a depressogenic manner)
lead to
2) Cognitive bias and disortions and automatic thoughts
Examples of biases:
1. Arbitrary inference
A conclusion drawn
on insufficient evidence
2. Selective abstraction- a conclusion
drawn on the basis of one bit of evidence
(usually negative) instead of all the evidence
3. Overgeneralization- a sweeping
conclusion drawn on the basis of s single,
perhaps trivial, event.
4. Magnification and minimization-
exagerations in evaluating performance
The research DOES suggest that depressed people manifest these symptoms BUT
other research suggests that depressed people are more accurate in their
thought processes while nondepressed people are the ones who are inaccurate
(usually in a self-aggradizing fashion).
Hopelessness Theory-
began with Seligman’s dogs who looked depressed after helplessness engendering
experiences
Revised theory= The particular pattern of attributions an individual makes
will determine their likelihood of displaying helplessness deficits
-the pattern is internal, stable and
global attributions for negative life
events of high importance.
Results of the Abramson, Metalsky and Alloy midterm study.
Another revision = hopelessness theory
Difficulties with hopelessness theory
1) Are the cognitive diatheses causes or symptoms
2) What type of depression are they talking about- We say it is hopelessness
depression- others say that makes the model circular and useless.
Suicide
One of the most serious symtoms and consequences of mood disorders is suicide
More than 50% of people who try and kill themselves are
despondent at the time of the act
-BUT not all people who go on to kill themselves are depressed (e.g. 13%
of schizophrenic patients go on to kill themselves, also a relationship with
alcoholism and personality disorders
Who kills themselves- Older white males have the highest suicide rate BUT
-suicide is third after accidents and homicides in reasons
for death ages 15-24
-this rate is rising-especially among
African-Americans
-more than 3000 15-19 year olds kill themselves each year
and children as young as six try it ( and have succeeded)
-majority if people who kill themselves have diagnosable
MI (MDD or ETOH)
- Physica Illness, either chronic (e.g. MS, or terminal,
e, g. AIDS is a contributing factor in at least ½
of all suicides
Myths about suicide:
1) People who talk about suicide don’t commit suicide (3/4 do)
2) Thinking about suicide is rare 40-80% of us think about suicide at least
once in our lives
3. Suicidal people clearly want to die
4. People of certain ethnic or social classes are particularly likely to
commit suicide
5. All people who commit suicide are depressed
6. To commit suicide is psychotic
7. Asking a person an bout suicide will “push him over the edge”
Schneidman- The Ten commonalities of suicide
1. The common purpose is to seek a solution
2. The common goal is the cessation of consciouness
3. The common stimulus is intolwerable psychological pain
4. The common stressor is frustrated psychological needs
5. The common emotion is hopelessness/helplessness
6. The common cognitive state is ambivalence
7. The common perceptual state is constriction
8. The common action is egression
9. The common interpersonal act is communication of intention.
10. The common consistency is lifelong coping patterns
Schneidman- Suicide prevention
1. Reduce the intense psychological pain and suffering
2. Expand the constricted view
3. Encourage the person to pull back even a little from the self-destructive
act
Personality Disorders- Coded on Axis II
-placed on a separate axis to make
sure that clinicians would pay
attention to their presence
-you can, and often do, have a comorbid
diagnosis on Axis II
We all possess SOME maladaptive personality traits that give us difficulties
at time
Personality disorders reflect a maladaptive STYLE of relating to other people
-a diagnosis is not made unless the difficulty is long
standing, pervasive and dysfunctional
e.g. we’re all paranoid at times but
to have a paranoid personality
disorder we must deal with the WORLD in a paranoid manner.
-defined in DSM-IV as enduring patterns of perceiving,
relating to, and thinking about the environment and oneself
that are exhibited in a wide range of personal and social
contexts
-must be displayed in at least two of the following areas:
1. Cognition (ways of perceiving and
interpreting onesself, other people and
events.
2. Affectivity (range, intensity,
lability, and appropriateness of emotional
response
3. Interpersonal functioning
4. Impulse control
- pattern must be stable and of long duration-onset can
be traced to adolescence or early childhood
-the code phrase in the DSM is “begins
in early adulthood and is present in a variety of contexts”
DSM-IV groups personality disorders into three clusters
Cluster A= Odd/Eccentric= paranoid, schizoid and schizotypal personality
disorder
Cluster B= Dramatic, Emotional or Erratic= antisocial, borderline, histrionic
and
narcissistic
Cluster C=Anxious/Fearful= avoidant, dependent, obsessive-compulsive
The Odd/Eccentric Cluster
1) Paranoid Personality Disorder (need at least 4 symptoms)
-essential feature is a pattern of pervasive distrust
and suspiciousness of others such that their motives are
interpreted as malevolent
-person expects to be mistreated and is constantly on
the lookout for signs of abuse
-usually preoccupied with doubts about others loyalty
-about a 1% prevalence rate
-occurs more often in men
-often comorbid with schizotypal, borderline and avoidant
-r/os include schizophrenia, other psychotic disorders
and substance abuse.
2) Schizoid Personality Disorder
-essential feature is a pervasive pattern of detachment
from social relationships and a restricted range of emotion
in interpersonal settings.
-seem to lack the desire for emotional intimacy, are “loners”
-appear indifferent to praise or criticism
-display constricted and restricted affect
-prevalence less than 1%
-slightly more common in men than women (causes more impairment
in men)
-r/os include schizophrenia, other psychotic disorders
and substance abuse
3) Schizotypal personality disorder.
-diagnosis derived from studying adopted children of schizophrenic
parent in Denmark
-children often displayed odd behavior
but were not schizophrenic.
-disorder first appeared in DSM-III
-essential feature is a pervasive pattern
of social and interpersonal deficits
marked by acute discomfort with, and reduced capacity for, close
relationships as well as by cognitive or perceptual
distortions and eccentricities
of behavior.
-show the interpersonal difficulties
of the schizoid PLUS social anxiety
(this is what differentiates it)
-also show odd beliefs or magical thinking
and illusions
-may show speech and appearance oddities
-ideas of reference (not delusions)
and paranoid ideation are also
common
-prevalence is aroud 3%
-more common in men than women
HUGE comorbidity with other PD dx (e.g. 59% also meet criteria for paranoid
personality disorder)
r/os include schizophrenia, other psychotic disorders and substance abuse
Etiology
Odd/eccentric disorders are less severe variants of Axis 1 Disorders
SOME family studies have shown that relatives of schizophrenic patients are
at increased risk for schizotypal PD
BUT other studies also find increased rates of schizotypal in relatives of
people with unipolar depressive disorder
SOME family studies have also found increased risk of paranoid personality
disorder in relatives of schizophrenics
THE TAKE HOME MESSAGE= the genetic evidence is unclear.
Neurological studies show deficits in cognitive and neuropsych problems as
welll as structural abnormalities that are also seen in schizophrenia.
Dramatic/erratic cluster- These are disorders characterized by highly variable
behavior and exaggerated displays of emotion
They include:
1. Borderline
2. Histrionic
3. Narcissistic
4. Antisocial
1. Borderline- adopted as a dx in 1980 The essential feature is a pervasive
pattern of instability of interpersonal relationships, self image, affects
and marked impulsivity that begins in eary adulthood and is present is a
variety of contexts
Need five or more symptoms such as:
1) frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment
2) a pattern of unstable and intence interpersonal relationships
3) identity disturbance = unstable self image or sense of self
4) impulsivity in at least 2 areas that are potentially self-damaging
5) recurrent suicidal behaviors or threats or self-mutilating behavior
6) affective instability due to marked reactivity of mood
7) chronic feelings of emptiness
8) inapproporaite intense anger or difficulty controlling anger
9) transient paranoid ideation or severe dissociative symptoms
-typically begins in adolescence
-prevalence is 1-2%
-likely to have a comorbid mood disorder or substance
abuse disorder
r/os = substance abuse, bipolar and almost any other PD
2) Histrionic personality disorder- the essential feature is pervasive and
excessive emotionality and attention-seeking behavior beginning by early
adulthood and present in a variety of contexts
Need at least 5:
1) uncomfortable in situations in which he or she is not the center of attention
2) interactions are often characterized by inappropriately seductive or provacative
behavior
3) displays rapidly shifting and shallow expression of emotions
4) consistently uses ohysical appearance to draw attention to self
5) speech is excessively impressionistic and lacking in detail
6) tends to dramatize and show exaggerated expression of emotion
7) is suggestible
8) considers relationships to be more intimate than they are
-prevalence is 2-3%
-more common in women than men
-comorbid with mood disorders and health problems
-highly comorbid with BPD
r/os= substance abuse, mood disorders and BPD
3. Narcissistic PD= The essential feature is a pervasive pattern of
grandiosity, need for admiration, and lack of empathy beginning in early
adulthood and present in a variety of contexts.
Need at least 5:
1. Grandiose sense of self-importance
2. Preoccupation with fantasies of unlimited success
3. Believe themselves special and can only be understood by very important
people
4. Requires excessive admiration
5. Has a sense of entitlement
6. In interpersonally exploitative
7. Lack empathy with wants and feelings of others
8. Is often envious of others or believes others are envious of him
or her
9. Is haughty and arrogant
-prevalence is less than 1%
-often comorbid with BPD
r/o bipolar, substance abuse
Antisocial PD= The essential feture is a pervasive pattern of disregard for
and violation of the rights of others that begins in CHILDHOOD or EARLY ADOLESCENCE
(by age 15) and is present in a variety of contexts
- the individual must be at least age 18 to be diagnosed
-APD involves a repetitive pattern of violation of the
basic rights or others or age appropriate social norms
that often begins with conduct disorder in childhood.
Need at least 3:
1) failure to conform to social norms as evidenced by repeatedly performing
acts that are grouds for arrest
2) repeateded deceitfulness
3) Impulsivity or failure to plan ahead
4) irritibility and aggressiveness, as indicated by repeated physical fights
or assaults
5. Reckless disregard for safety of self or others
6. Concictent irresponsibility as indicated by repeated failure to sustain
consistent work behavior or honor financial obligations
7. Lack of remorse as indicated by being indifferent to or rationalizing
harm done to another
r/o = schitz, bipolar and substance abuse
Does NOT apply to all criminals (only 15-25% of convicted
felons meet the critieria
-prevalence 3% of adult American men and 1% of women
-often comorbid with a substance abuse diagnosis
Etiology of dramatic/erratic cluster
Genetics and antisocial
Kohut/ Mahler and Narcissistic, histrionic
Hernber and BPD and unstable object introjects
Cluster 3- Anxious/Fearful Cluster
Avoidant Personality Disorder
1) The essential feature is a pervasive pattern of social inhibition, feelings
of inadequacy and hypersensitivity to negative evaluation that begins by
early adulthood and is present in a variety of contexts
Need at least four:
1) avoids occupational activities that involve significant interpersonal
contact because of fears of criticism, disapproval or rejuection
2) is unwilling to get involved with people unless certain of being liked
3) shows restraint within interpersonal relationships because of the fear
of being shamed or ridiculed (always doubting others sincerity
4) is preoccupied with being criticised or rejected in social situations
5) is inhibited in new interpersonal situations because of feelings of inadequacy
6) views self as socially inept, personally unappealing, or inferior to others
7) is unually reluctant to take personal risks or engage in new activites
because of fears of embarassment.
-1% prevalence
-often comorbid with dependent and
BPD
-VERY often comorbid with generalized
social phobia
Dependent Personality Disorder
1) The essential feature is a pervasive and excessive need to be taken care
of which leads to submissive and clining behavior and fears of seperation.
Need at least five:
1) has difficulty making everyday decisions without excessive amount of advice
and reassurance from others.
2) needs others to assume responsibility for most major areas of his or her
life.
3) has difficulty expressing disagreement with others because of fear of
loss of support or approval.
4) has difficulty expressing disagreemnet with others because of fear of
loss of support or disapproval
5) has difficulty initiating projects or doing things on his or her own because
of a lack of self-confidence NOT motivation
6) goes to excessive lengths to obtain nurturance and support from others
to the point of volunteering to do things which are unpleasant.
7) feels uncomfotable or helpless when alone because of exaggerated fears
of being unable to care for him or herself.
8) urgently seeks another relationship as a source of care and support when
a close relationship ends
9) is unrealistically preoccupied with fears of being left to take care of
him or herself.
--prevalence about 1.5%
-more women than men
-first degree relative high in mood and anxiety disorders
-often comorbid with BPD and avaoidant as well as Axis
One and health problems
3) Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder
1) The essential feature is a preoccupation with orderliness, perfectionism
and mental and interpersonal control, at the expense of flexibility, openness
and efficiency
Need at least four:
1) is preoccupied with details and rules to the extent that the major point
of the activity is lost.
2) shows perfectionism that interferes with task completion
3) is excessively devoted to work and productiivity to the exclusion of leisure
activities and friendships (not accounted for by economic necessity)
4) is overconscientious, scrupulous and inflexible about matters of morality,
ethics or values
5) is unable to discard worout or worthless objects even when they have no
sentimental value
6) is reluctant to delegate tasks or work with others unless they submit
to his or her way of doing things
7) adopts a miserly spending style to self and others
8) shows rigidity and stubbornness
Etiology
Two types of symptoms:
1) difficulties with dependence
2) difficulties with attachment
Ainsworth= these disorders reflect an anxious attachment style
P/A= fixation at the anal stage
Therapy
1) Psychotropics for mood symptoms
2) Object-relations therapy= reparenting
3) Cognitive therapy looking at maladaptive schemata
Substance Related Disorders 2 categories
Distinguish between substance use, abuse and dependence
1) Substance abuse
need at least one:
A. Failure to fulfill major obligations
e.g. absence from work or neglect of children
B. Recurrent substance use in
physically dangerous situations (e.g. driving
or operating machinery)
C. Recurrent substance related
legal problems (e.g. arrests)
D. Continued substance use despite
persistent or recurrent social or interpersonal
problems caused by the substance (e.g. arguments with
spouse about intoxication)
2) Substance dependence
need at least three
A. Tolerance
1. Need for markedly increased
amount of the drug to achieve the
desired effect
2. Markedly diminished effect
with the same dose
B. Withdrawal (includes using the drug to avoid
withdrawal)
C. The substance is taken in larger amount than
intended or for longer periods
than intended
D. There is a persistent desire or unsuccessful
efforts to cut down on substance
use
E. A great deal of time is spent in activities necessary
to obtain the substance
F. Important social, occupational or recreational
activities are given up or
reduced because of substance use.
G. The substance use is continued despite knowledge
of having a recurrent psychological
or physical problem that is caused by the substance
Solomon= Opponent Process Theory
1995 Survey 52% had used ETOH in the past month
28.8 had used cigarettes
4.7 had used marijuana
less than 1% had used other drugs
People who start drinking early (in teens) usually develop first withdrawal
symptoms in their thirties
Abrupt withdrawal from alcohol can be fatal in highly dependent people
-Symptoms include anxiety, insomnia, restlessness and
depression
-In rare cases the person experiences delirium tremens
-= the person may become delirious
and experience tactile and visual hallucinations
lifetime prevalence> 20% for men and 8% for women
-but rates for younger women approach male rates
-highest rates among whites and latinos are in 18-29 year
old group
-highest rates among Afican American are in 30-44 year
old group
- common among Native Americans and associated with 40%
of deaths and virtually all crimes
- for women time between heavy drinking and abuse is especially
brief
-women are more likely than men to
be steady drinkers, to drink alone but are
less likely to engage in binge drinking.
The financial cost of ETOH abuse is est. At 125 billion
Short-term effects- strongly related to the drinkers expectations (e.g. some
people report that ETOH acts as an aphrodiasiac BUT it actually inhibits
sexual performance)
ETOH has a biphasic effect
Initial effect is stimulating but than acts as a depressant
ETOH stimulates GABA receptors= anxiolytic effect
-Also increases serotonin and dopamine levels =reinforcing
effect
-Also inhibits glutamate receptors= cognitive effect
Long-term effects
Almost every organ is affected by ETOH. Produces:
1) malnutrition
2) amnestic syndrome
3) Cirrhosis (9th leading cause of death in U.S.)
4) hemorrage, including capillary hemorrage
5) FAS
6) Destroys families
Smoking
Nicotine is the addicting agent
the other harmful products include carbon monoxide and tar
Smoking is directly or indirectly responsible for 1-6 deaths in the U.S.
and kills more than 1100 people each day
-kills more people than AIDS, car accidents, cocaine,
crack, heroin, homocide
and suicide combined
-of the 1000 children and adolescents who begin smoking
every day 750 will die a smoking related death
-besides death associated with chronic URI, various cancers
the financial cost to the U.S. of smoking is around 178 million dollars a
day
- second hand smoke causes 50,000 deaths a year
About 25% of American adults still smoke (40% in 1965)
-BUT the rate is incresing among teenagers
-BUT prevalence has declined less among women than men
-prevalence is lowest among college graduates and those
over age 75
Health risks decline to near normal levels 5-10 years after quitting
Marijuana
-hashish is derived from the resin of marijuana plants
-marijuana legal until 1920
- the active chemical is THC and is more potent than it
used to be
-THC directly affects cannibis receptors in the brain
Use has increased in the 1990s (was on the decline)
-effect range from mild relation to hallucinations and
severe mood swings but almost always
involves some cognitive and psychomotor impairment
-Long term use may cause STM impairment
Therapeutic effects
Psychological vs. Physiological addiction
Cocaine (Freud) also used to be legal
types of use =snoting, freebase and injection
act as an anesthetic
also blocks reuptake of dopamine=euphoria
is a vasoconstrictor= strokes
EXTREMELY addictive (esp. crack) and causes a severe withdrawal syndrome
prevalence= .8% for 18-34 year olds
chronic use =mood swings and paranoia
crack babies
Depressants= a drug that acts on the CNS to reduce pain, tension, anxiety-
a relaxant
1) opiates induce reverie and reduce anxiety and pain
1) opium
2) morphine
3) heroin (stronger and more addictive)
4) methadone satisfies cravings w/o a “high”
“Imagine that every cell in your body has a tongue and they are all licking
honey”
1) N/V
2) rapid tolerance
3) withdrawal begins in 4-6 hours ax, craving and physio sx
2) Tranquilizers and barbiturates (Nembutal & Seconal)
dependence often begins with insomnia
3) Stimulants (other than crack)
amphetamines (paranoid schizophrenia)
caffeine
4) Halluciongens
marijuana (THC)
causes
1) decreases in testosterone
2) supporession of immune reactions
3) lung damage
4) impaired judgment and apathy
Drugs and brain chemistry
Drugs and personality factors
Treatment
1) Detox
2) 12 step programs
3) Biological treatments (e.g. Antabuse)
4) CBT (e.g. aversion therapy or operant conditioning)
5) replacement therapy = patch or methadone